On 4-1 Vote, Select Board Decides To Double Overtime Parking Ticket Fines
JohnCarl McGrady •
The Select Board voted 4-1 on Wednesday to double overtime parking fines from $25 to $50 in an effort to deter people from intentionally parking longer than is allowed in downtown spots and treating the fines as simply the cost of the parking space.
“For me, anecdotally, the ticketing works, and theoretically, a higher fine will disincentivize another round of people from accepting overtime fines as a cost of life or business,” Select Board vice chair Brooke Mohr said.
Of course, the fines will apply to everyone who parks in a space for too long, regardless of the reason. The lone vote against the proposal came from Bob DeCosta, who worried that doubling the fines would hurt island residents who have to park downtown for work.
“There’s a lot of people who are working people who sometimes have to park downtown,” DeCosta said. “They can’t leave their job exactly 30 minutes or an hour later to move their car and they’re going to get tickets, and when you’re only making minimum wage working somewhere and you get a $50 dollar ticket, or two $50 dollar tickets, it’s a hit. And this is not going to stop people from parking for three or four hours straight. They’re just going to pay $50 or $100.”
Representatives of Cape Cod Express and FedEx also suggested that the change would not significantly deter wealthy island residents and visitors from parking in downtown spots longer than is permitted.
Notably, the change will make it more expensive to receive an overtime parking ticket than it costs to park in the designated valet lot downtown. Previously, the tickets for ostensibly illegal parking were cheaper than the valet lot.
“The goal isn’t to influence everybody. The goal is to influence 5, 10, 20 percent of the people,” Select Board member Matt Fee said. “This is just a step.”
According to town staff and Fee, it has been decades since the town’s overtime parking fines were last adjusted.
“This is long overdue in my opinion,” Select Board member Jill Vieth said.
The town collected $371,000 in overtime parking ticket revenue last year, and $221,500 the year before. While the fines have been doubled, the hope is that the revenue will rise by at least slightly less: in theory, higher fines will lead to a lower number of violations.
Some members of the public suggested that they would like to see the fines raised even higher, or that they would support an escalating fee structure, in which each successive ticket costs more than the one before it. But police chief Jody Kasper said that neither of these options is legal under state law.