When Facts Fail

To the editor: In the most recent opinion letter by Burton Balkind of the Nantucket Coastal Conservancy, he makes a point about the “facts” of paying for the relocation of the alternative road access along Baxter Road. He states that the betterment tax will pay for a “large percentage” of the costs of moving the homes. While this may be partially true, it doesn't cover the whole story.

The homeowners along Baxter agreed to work with the town to obtain easements for the road if the town acted in good faith to pursue the geotube project. This approach can mitigate the cost for the town significantly by working with the homeowners. However, if this partnership breaks down, it is almost certain that any number of lawsuits costing millions of dollars will be filed against any efforts at eminent domain. Are these costs reflected in the “facts” Burton states? No.

Secondly, the town’s budget for fiscal year 2026 is public record and shows clearly that real estate taxes play a significant role in covering municipal operations and programs. For FY 2026, real estate taxes are expected to contribute approximately 75% of the town's total revenue. If the town allows homes along the ocean to not be protected, the revenue base will depreciate, hurting everyone. Are the loss of real estate tax dollars reflected in Burton’s “facts”? No.

A collaborative approach could set a powerful precedent, showing that small communities can not only survive but thrive by working together.

Beth Albrecht Singer
Baxter Road Homeowner