Current Real Estate Roundup - December 28, 2025

This week’s Current Real Estate Roundup includes property transfers from December 18, 2025 to December 24, 2025. It is led by the sale of a Cato Lane property for over $7.5 million and a Plover Lane property for over $5.5 million.

27 Cato Lane for $7,850,000 from Cato LLC to Cato Rental LLC. The property is .51 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee was exempt. The assessed value of the property is $2,686,800.

Property Description: "It’s official - the wait is over. This unparalleled expansive Nantucket property offers everything you’ve been dreaming of: three newly constructed dwellings, six private ensuite bedrooms, two bunk rooms, a separate studio, and sun-drenched interiors throughout, all centered around a sparkling southern-facing 16' x 40' pool on a beautifully landscaped half-acre in coveted South of Town. With effortless access to downtown, Cisco, and Miacomet’s beaches and amenities, this property delivers the perfect blend of luxury, convenience, and room to roam. Whether entertaining family and friends or planning future additions like a sports court, the possibilities are endless."

14 Plover Lane for $5,875,000 from ACK-TU LLC to 14 Plover Lane LLC. The property is .92 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $117,500 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $4,493,400.

Property Description: "This newly built custom home features five bedrooms, and six and one half baths and is a short distance to its deeded ocean beach. Enter into the spacious front foyer from the covered porch and go directly back to the great room. The home is beautifully designed and custom-built, completed in 2023. The common rooms are perfectly laid out to accommodate friends and family. The living room has a gas fireplace. The dining room has custom built-ins. The Kitchen is outfitted with the highest quality appliances, featuring a walk-in pantry with an additional Sub Zero refrigerator. There is a family/coffee/wine room with a bar sink, drinks fridge, Miele espresso/coffee maker, wine cooler and custom wine rack. The private back patio overlooks a wooded conservation area. The two-car garage is finished with an epoxy floor. Walk-out basement with heated floors and a full bath is spotless and ready to be re-imagined. There is a backup generator, sound system, vacuum system, water filtration system, permit for 8 x 20 pool, and outdoor shower."

134C Main Street for $4,700,000 from Kristine Shadek to Heather S. Nicholls and Malcolm B. Nicholls III, Trustees of the Heather St. Onge Nicholls Trust – 2004. The property is .11 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $94,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,375,600.

Property Description: "This hidden gem was built in 1915 and housed Cady's Bakery, one of the first bakeries on Nantucket. The property is tucked off Main Street down a shell way, offering an unexpectedly private and quiet location, yet close to downtown shops and restaurants. The house is larger than expected offering an open floor plan with cathedral ceilings, stone gas fire place, and four bedrooms (two with vaulted ceilings), and four bathroom (three bedrooms are ensuite). Many details of the building were preserved including exposed beams and a sliding barn door. New elements include central AC, a gas fireplace, a covered porch, a finished lower level, and multiple stone patio areas outside for eating and lounging. Additional updates include a new cedar roof, copper gutters, exterior lighting, a gas line for the grill, a shed, and a foot bath/ dog wash. The property has a spacious covered porch and three patios, one is located in the front yard offering a sunny spot for early morning light, another in the side yard providing a perfect spot to enjoy the afternoon sun and a third patio is located off the living room for alfresco dining. The patios are connected by a fenced in yard."

13 Cedar Circle Units 1 & 2 for $2,600,000 from Anastasia Cher & Sean K. Reid & ZWA LLC to The Theatre Workshop of Nantucket Inc. The property’s acreage is N/A, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee was exempt. The assessed value of the property is $1,246,600.

10 Coffin Street, 25R & 27 Washington Street for $2,500,000 from James A. Noyes, Carolyn N. Hewitt, and Rainbow Trust to The Nantucket Maria Mitchell Association. The property’s acreage is N/A, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee was exempt. The assessed value of the property is N/A.

29 Fair Street for $2,400,000 from 27 Fair Street LLC to 21A Pleasant Street LLC. The property is .11 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $48,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $3,156,800.

Property Description: "Originally built in 1709 for the George Bunker family. The property was converted to the Woodbox Inn in 1931. Located at the top of the hill, on one of Nantucket's most charming streets, 29 Fair Street is a rare opportunity to restore a piece of Nantucket's architectural heritage that's steeped in history. Many original features are still intact. Potential for sub-division."

14 Pequot Street for $2,000,000 from Surfside Blue Chip LLC to Surfside Blue Chip LLC. The property is 1.24 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $40,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,121,600.

103A Old South Road for $1,425,000 from Estate of Elihu S. Tuttle III to Marko Medic and Viktoriya Angelova. The property is .46 acres, vacant land, and a Land Bank fee of $4,500 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $815,400.

1 Toombs Court (Lot C) for $1,000,000 from Toombs Court LLC to First Rochester Parcel C LLC. The property is .22 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $20,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $1,260,706.