Judge Finds Driver Not Guilty In Tom Nevers Road Accident That Injured Island Attorney
David Creed •
The driver who was charged with negligence after striking island attorney Steven Cohen with his motor vehicle while he was jogging on Tom Nevers Road in the summer of 2024 was found not guilty by Nantucket District Court Judge John Julian Tuesday afternoon following a bench trial.
Brendan J. Lafferty, 28, of Nantucket, was facing charges of negligent operation of a motor vehicle and operating a motor vehicle without an inspection sticker stemming from the accident on July 9, 2024. Julian said that while the crash was a “horrific, horrific accident,” there was not enough evidence to indicate Lafferty had been driving negligently. Lafferty had previously waived his right to a trial by jury.
"The court has a search warrant for the black box of the motor vehicle," Julian said prior to announcing his verdict. "The Commonwealth has this information and did not present any evidence (from it). So what is the fact finder left to do to infer that there wasn't any information on there that would support an excessive speed, or that there was something inside the motor vehicle that was the fault of Mr. Lafferty.
“This is a horrific accident. Horrific,” Julian continued. “This is something that's changed the lives of not only Mr. Cohen but certainly in some respects Mr. Lafferty. He was behind the wheel of an accident that caused these injuries. But again, accidents sometimes are just accidents, and I don't have enough evidence to say that this is not just an accident. The evidence that the Commonwealth presented was insufficient for me to make that finding, based on all of the evidence, the pictures, and all of the things that they offered but there's no explanation as to what it was. So, based on all of that, I'm going to find the defendant not guilty.”
During the trial, it was revealed that Cohen was left paralyzed from the spinal cord injury he suffered during the accident. The prosecution said he remains in an off-island facility. Cohen appeared via Zoom during the trial to observe the proceedings, but did not speak. He shared the following statement with the Current later Tuesday afternoon:
"I'm very disappointed," Cohen said. "I think this was a lot more than just an accident and it couldn't have impacted my life more. But I really appreciate all the support I get from everybody on Nantucket."
According to the police report, Nantucket Police officers were dispatched to Tom Nevers Road at approximately 6:52 a.m. on July 9th, 2024 after receiving a report that a motor vehicle had struck a pedestrian. Upon arrival, police said that the vehicle had significant damage to the passenger’s side front end and that the police observed Cohen on the ground perpendicular to the roadway approximately five yards from the white fog line on Tom Nevers Road.
Lafferty told police that he was driving down the road when he suddenly heard a thump. He exited his vehicle, saw he had struck a pedestrian, and called 911. Police said they observed “various papers and books on the dashboard directly in front of the steering wheel impeding the visibility of the operator.”
Lafferty said in his statements to police that he was driving five to 10 miles per hour below the posted speed limit of 40 miles per hour that morning. Given the Cape & Islands District Attorney's Office did not provide any information from the Nantucket Police or Massachusetts State Police investigations that indicated Lafferty was driving faster than the speed limit, Julian said there was no reason for him to believe Lafferty was driving at a speed over the limit. Otherwise, he said, the Commonwealth would have presented that information.
During the bench trial, NPD officer Seamus McArdle testified that when he arrived at the accident scene, he observed approximately 10 items on the vehicle's dashboard and a side-view mirror and headlight were removed from the vehicle. NPD Sergeant Michael Mastriano, who was also one of the officers to respond to the scene, testified that he was forced to change how he was driving due to the foggy conditions that morning. Officer Dan Furtado said during his testimony that he had a difficult time driving because of the fog and drove below the speed limit because he was afraid of hitting a deer.
The only member of the Nantucket Police Department trained at the time to complete accident reconstruction reports was Deputy Police Chief Charlie Gibson. Gibson was at the scene, managing the accident assessment and providing instructions on what to photograph. None of the police officers who testified said they saw the report filed by Gibson, and the prosecution did not submit any contents from Gibson’s investigation – leading Julian to suggest there is no reason to believe Gibson’s findings indicated Lafferty was negligent or distracted that morning.
An island woman who was Lafferty’s landlord at the time in Tom Nevers was called by the defense. During her testimony, she recalled the morning as being, “the foggiest morning she has ever seen” on Nantucket and that she has lived on the island for decades. She said when she looked outside that morning, she just saw white fog and “couldn’t even see (her) driveway.” She said she could maybe see seven to eight feet from her door to the end of the porch.
“I told (Lafferty) to make sure his fog lights were on, to drive slow, and watch the yellow line,” she testified. “She said later that morning she went outside and saw Lafferty in the backyard with his hands in the air and crying.”
Cohen, whose home is located nearby in Tom Nevers, was rushed by ambulance to Nantucket Cottage Hospital, while police officers remained at the scene with the road temporarily blocked off in both directions near the intersection with Lyons Lane.
During the trial, the 911 call was played for Julian. In it, Lafferty reports hitting Cohen on the side of the road and when asked by dispatch if the man was alright, Lafferty said, “No he is not alright. He is unconscious.”
Just before 9 a.m. that morning, a Coast Guard Jayhawk helicopter landed in the thick fog at Nantucket Memorial Airport to transport Cohen to a Boston hospital, as MedFlight was unable operate in the conditions that day. Cohen and Lafferty were the only people involved in the incident.
During his closing argument, Lafferty’s attorney Peter Lloyd said Cohen was wearing dark grey clothing in the fog and running on a road without a sidewalk. He claimed Cohen had an earbud in while listening to a podcast and was also running on the wrong side of the road. According to Lloyd, the statute to find someone guilty of negligent operation of a motor vehicle states that someone can’t be found guilty just because the individual hit someone with their vehicle.
Assistant District Attorney Aine Dillon asked Julian to find Lafferty guilty – arguing that the Commonwealth had met its burden and proved all three points beyond a reasonable doubt that Lafferty drove negligently.
“He should have been driving slower. He should have taken more care. He should have had his windshield cleared of objects obstructing his view,” Dillon said. Dillon added Cohen only wore one AirPod rather than both so he could “hear his surroundings.”
“He is in a wheelchair with damage to his vertebrae, unable to move any of his four extremities,” Dillon said. “His life looks very, very different than it did before July 9th of 2024. A reasonable person, like the officers testified to, drove slower to work that morning. (Lafferty) should have too.”
According to Massachusetts law, to prove the negligent operation of a motor vehicle charge beyond a reasonable doubt against Lafferty, the Cape & Islands District Attorney’s Office had to establish three elements:
1) That Lafferty was driving the vehicle
2) The driving occurred on a public way, or in a place where the public has a right of access or access as invitees or licensees.
3) That Lafferty drove “negligently while failing to use the care a reasonable driver would use under the circumstances, such that the lives or safety of the public might have been endangered.”
Judge John Julian said after reviewing all of the exhibits and testimony, he found there wasn’t enough evidence to find Lafferty guilty of the crime.