Citizen Petitions Seek To Revise And Overturn Somerset Sewer Expansion

Ten citizen petitions were submitted for the 2027 Annual Town Meeting, including one seeking to radically increase the transparency of town finances.

JohnCarl McGrady •

IMG 5508
Nantucket's legislative town government body - the Annual Town Meeting - in 2023. Photo by Jason Graziadei

Last spring, voters overwhelmingly approved a $45 million expansion of the town’s sewer system into the Somerset area. Then, after the vote, some of the area’s residents came out against the expansion. On Tuesday, the town released a list of citizen warrant articles that will be included on this spring’s Annual Town Meeting warrant, and there are several from Somerset Road residents seeking to revise or overturn the spring’s votes.

One, from Jeffrey Allen, would make connecting to the expansion optional for homeowners with existing, functional septic systems, arguing that, “the mandatory requirement to connect to sewer lines places an undue financial burden on homeowners in this predominantly year-round community.” Those property owners would still have to connect to the sewer lines when their septic systems failed, but it would buy them time—and delay the full implementation of the article voters approved last spring.

Another, sponsored by John Fones, would require the town to install pumping stations to handle the movement of sewage from properties that cannot use gravity feeds, and would exempt homeowners who cannot use gravity feeds from having to connect to the sewer until those pumping stations are provided.

Finally, a proposal from Karen Alence would overturn the vote from the last Town Meeting and reallocate legally available authorized funding to pay for the dredging and restoration of Miacomet Pond instead. Alence argues that shifting the funds to the pond project would improve Nantucket’s water quality without an expanded sewer system.

Somerset needs area
The Somerset Sewer Needs Area, where the town voted in May 2026 to provide new sewer service. Graphic via NLWC

It is unclear how feasible Alence’s proposal is. By the time voters have a chance to weigh in at Town Meeting, the town may have already agreed to contracts committing some or all of the funding for the sewer expansion.

Aside from the sewer-related articles, one of the more notable citizen proposals on the warrant is a lengthy article sponsored by former firefighter Beau Barber that would dramatically increase the town’s financial transparency.

Barber’s article would make large amounts of information about municipal financial transactions, including those related to employee payroll, available to the public. The article, which has broad applicability, would require the town to make “all transaction records continuously available through an open data portal” that would have to be updated at least daily.

The article would completely change the town’s existing disclosure policies. In recent years, the town has provided progressively less information to reporters, making municipal and public safety records harder to obtain and making it increasingly difficult to interview town personnel. But, if passed, Barber’s proposal would provide more access to the town’s financial information than has ever been given before.

Screen Shot 2025 05 04 at 11 51 05 PM
Beau Barber speaking at the 2025 Annual Town Meeting on the non-binding Town Council question.

Only a short list of information categories, such as personally identifying information like bank account numbers and home addresses, would be allowed to be withheld. Producing and redacting these records would likely be expensive.

Only 10 citizen warrant articles were submitted this year, one more than last year but far fewer than the 26 submitted the year before. This is a low number by Nantucket’s recent standards, despite the lack of a Special Town Meeting this fall, which sometimes siphons away proposals that would otherwise end up on the spring warrant.

Additionally, the Select Board is trimming the number of override spending proposals on the warrant, eliminating many of the articles that often draw the most controversy. As a consequence, this may be one of the shortest Annual Town Meeting warrants—and potentially one of the shortest Annual Town Meetings—in recent Nantucket history.

Another citizen warrant article that may draw some debate seeks an investigation of the recent independent review of the original investigation into the 2018 African Meeting House hate crime. Filed by Clifford Williams, who has long been one of the island’s most outspoken critics of the town’s response to the racist graffiti that was spray-painted on the building, the article is the latest salvo in a fight that has now dragged on for eight years.

In theory, the fight was supposed to end this summer with the release of an independent investigation into the town’s conduct during the initial response to the hate crime. But that investigation had already drawn some fire from community advocates before it was released, and those advocates were not happy with the report, which found “no evidence suggesting the incident was ignored or intentionally minimized,” but did suggest that the investigation failed to follow up on all potential leads, which could have hampered efforts to identify the perpetrator.

IMG 6424
Clifford Williams campaigning in May 2025. Photo by Jason Graziadei

Williams, who is himself a perennial Select Board candidate, continued to press the Select Board on the investigation for months after the report was released. Now, he appears set to take the fight back to Town Meeting, where voters previously backed the independent investigation into the town’s handling of the crime.

Other citizen warrant articles include a renewed proposal from island resident Curtis Barnes to establish a town council form of government, a goal he has pursued for years; an attempt to allow storage containers by special permit in the Commercial Mid Island (CMI) zoning district; a petition from former Planning Board member Hillary Hedges Rayport seeking to push rear-lot subdivisions toward affordable and attainable housing; a request from former Select Board member Rick Atherton to change the relationship between the town and the Nantucket Planning and Economic Development Commission and its employees, including planning director Leslie Snell; and a request from Fairgrounds Restaurant proprietor Ethan Devine to move his establishment from a residential zone to the commercial neighborhood zoning district.

Current News