No Music After 10PM At The Gazebo? Select Board Limits Entertainment License For New Operator
JohnCarl McGrady •
The new operator of The Tavern & The Gazebo was granted licenses by the Select Board on Monday to reopen the two iconic establishments with one major caveat: The Gazebo will be required to turn off its music at 10 p.m.
In the past, the Gazebo has been allowed to play music until it closed at 1:00 a.m. But after former operator Luke Tedeschi did not have his lease renewed by real estate mogul Steve Karp’s Nantucket Island Resorts this fall, the new operator — a management team led by restaurateur Steve Silverstein — had to apply for an entertainment license, which gave the Select Board the chance to tighten the conditions.
And tighten them they did.
“To me, it makes sense, from an enforcement point of view, for the police department, that we align these outdoor entertainment licenses to our noise bylaw, and that way, I think both the neighbors and everyone else can understand,” Select Board vice chair Brooke Mohr said, referencing the Nantucket noise bylaw that generally prohibits amplified outdoor music after 10 p.m.
Select Board member Bob DeCosta, who was recused from the vote on the license because he is considered an abutter of the Gazebo with his charter boat slip at nearby Straight Wharf, sparked the conversation about the establishment’s hours when he spoke up as a private citizen.
“My boat is just on the other side of [the Gazebo], less than 100 yards away. It’s loud,” DeCosta said. “I put up with it for all these years because it was a pre-existing license, but I have some concerns. I can’t sleep on my boat. If I have an earlier charter and I want to leave at 4:00 in the morning and I just want to go down and sleep on my boat, I can’t do that.”
Most downtown establishments have to stop all outdoor entertainment at 10:00 p.m., in keeping with Nantucket’s noise ordinance, but The Gazebo was - until now - an exception. The other exceptions, according to licensing administrator Amy Baxter, are Ventuno’s back bar, and the so-called “Tree Bar” between Town restaurant and Queequeg’s. Several board members and Baxter indicated the town should attempt to bring all licensed establishments into alignment over time by addressing those exceptions.
“I think we should be consistent with this,” Select Board chair Dawn Hill said.
Select Board member Jill Vieth expressed some reservations about the vote, but ultimately went along with it in an effort to increase consistency across town.
“It just seems like kind of a big change,” she said. “I’m all for the consistency, so I very much support that, but I…would really like to get their feedback about how that goes.”
Select Board member Matt Fee also said that he felt a “a little torn,” and attempted to carve out an allowance for the Gazebo’s televisions to be on beyond the 10:00 p.m. limit so that it would only apply to music.
“I would like to do some more work on it and think it through a little more,” Fee said. “Could we have it be no music after ten, let the TV be on?”
His efforts, however, were unsuccessful, and he voted with the rest of the board in the end.
“I actually think a TV is potentially worse,” Mohr said. “I’m inclined to go with less and then accept a request to add at a later date.”
The Select Board also approved the liquor license permit for the Gazebo and One Harbor, which will replace Tedeschi’s Tavern, with relatively little discussion, though the approval will remain conditional until Tedeschi’s existing liquor license for the location expires or is transferred this January.