Select Board Rejects License Requests For DJs During Christmas Stroll

The discussion at Monday's licensing meeting delved into what the annual Christmas Stroll has become, versus what it should be.

JohnCarl McGrady •

Stroll Chamber 135 e3a40f7172c3e2402cbe8afa5c931de5
Santa arrived on Straight Wharf shortly during the 2025 Christmas Stroll event. Photo by Charity Grace Mofsen

The Select Board voted Monday to block several establishments from hosting DJs at this year’s Christmas Stroll, part of a push to rein in the holiday celebration after last year’s event featured a brawl and high-profile liquor license violations.

“Last year was just a very bad look for the island,” Select Board member Jill Vieth said. “I really thought that was disappointing and I would hate to see that continue and get worse.”

During the discussion, Select Board member Bob Decosta suggested that Stroll, the annual seasonal celebration sponsored by the island’s Chamber of Commerce, has lost its character. What was once a family-friendly holiday festival, they said, has become something more akin to a liquor-fueled party.

“They’re restaurants that are trying to be nightclubs for one weekend a year,” DeCosta said. “Stroll was never about this being a party thing. Stroll was about people coming here and getting in the Christmas spirit. You want to play Christmas music? Play Christmas music. But you don’t need a DJ and a dance floor in there turning it into a damn rave. This isn’t South Beach, so I am not in favor of any of these DJs.”

Two local establishments, Billie’s and the Green Room at the Greydon House, had requested DJs. Billie’s had also requested an external speaker, which licensing administrator Amy Baxter recommended against. A third establishment, The Boarding House, pulled its request for a DJ ahead of the meeting after learning that town staff planned to recommend against the proposal.

Anna Worgess-Smith, the managing partner at Billie’s, said during the hearing that the restaurant had only requested the DJ in an effort to convince more people to attend a fundraiser for the Nantucket Food Pantry that they were hosting on Sunday afternoon, the day after the main event of Stroll. The fundraiser, intended to feature a raffle, would not be anything like a nightclub, she said.

“The DJ will only be performing during the hours of food service, and we deliberately kept him away from the first floor in the bar area to hopefully avoid there being that club/party sort of atmosphere,” she said. “We were just doing it because we are planning to sell tickets, and you need a reason on that Sunday to get people to come.”

Green Room bar manager Shannyn Trujillo characterized their plans as relatively constrained: a single DJ with no dance floor playing for only about two hours.

“It’s all inside,” she said. “We are a hotel as well, so it’s not going to get to that crazy club level.”

After some discussion, the Select Board voted against both requests, raising concerns about the noise the one-day entertainment permits could generate.

“I think we should be consistent in whatever we do,” Select Board vice chair Brooke Mohr said.

The decision does not affect other restaurants that already have standing entertainment licenses that allow DJs.

Screen Shot 2025 12 07 at 10 46 38 PM e3a40f7172c3e2402cbe8afa5c931de5
A scene from the brawl that broke out on Federal Street after starting inside The Boarding House during the 51st Nantucket Christmas Stroll in December 2025. Video screenshot

The Pearl and The Boarding House initially requested a DJ as well, but after Baxter recommended against the request ahead of Monday's meeting, the establishments withdrew the request. The brawl that garnered international news attention at last year’s Stroll started inside The Boarding House, near where the DJ was performing, before spilling out onto Federal Street.

The Select Board did authorize sushi spot Bar Yoshi to erect a tent over its outdoor dining area, but reiterated that no bar was allowed outside. Bar Yoshi currently has a two-day liquor license suspension hanging over its head after multiple violations at last year’s stroll, including serving alcohol in open containers at an outdoor bar without permission.

The town’s licensing department will continue to accept further entertainment license applications for Stroll until November 20th.

Chamber of Commerce executive director Peter Burke also joined the Select Board meeting to inform the board that the Chamber is distributing “stroll like a pro” messaging discouraging open containers and reminding visitors to be on their best behavior. The Chamber is also hiring a paid “Stroll ambassador” to help spread the message.

Current News