State Approves New Public Water Well And Increased Water Use For Nantucket

The state Department of Environmental Protection signed off on the new well and water consumption increase amid an ongoing drought.

Jason Graziadei •

DJI 20260415134356 0033 D
The Wannacomet Water Company water tower at North Pasture, off Polpis Road, where a new deep well will be tapped. Photo by Jason Graziadei

Nantucket Water Department director Mark Willett announced late last week that the island has received state approval to add a new public water well off Polpis Road and a significant increase in Nantucket’s annual water withdrawal permit.

For Willett, it was the culmination of an effort that began seven years ago, and one that has become all the more necessary since then as the island’s water use has continued to grow.

The new Well 17, planned for years at the Wannacomet Water Company’s North Pasture property off Polpis Road, will be its largest-capacity well and pumping station once construction is complete. The state also approved a significant increase to Nantucket’s water withdrawal permit, raising it to 2.42 million gallons per day (MGD) from the previous limit of 2.02 MGD.

Willett credited the Nantucket Land Bank Commission for voting in April to set aside a parcel of land off Milestone Road for drinking water mitigation, which allowed for a greater increase to the island’s water withdrawal permit.

“We were going to be at 2.2 (MGD), but because of our work with the Land Bank in locking up certain properties for conservation for water purposes only - all the land around our North Pasture tank and well 14 and well 17,” Willett told the Nantucket Water Commission last Thursday. “The Land Bank has put that in kind of a trust that the DEP approved as conservation for water, and then you get credit. So from now until 2031, we can pump 2.42 million gallons of water a day.”

The approvals come as the island continues to deal with drought conditions that have slightly abated in recent months, but remain persistent as Nantucket’s rainfall has remained well below average for three years running. The drought prompted mandatory water use restrictions over the summer, including a ban on automatic irrigation, for all properties connected to the municipal water system. Users responded by significantly cutting back their water use by more than 100 million gallons.

Nantucket rainfall line graph 1995 2026 ytd

The new permit increases the total amount of water Nantucket can withdraw from the aquifer in a given year.

“So yearly we can go up to 883 million gallons of water pumped,” Willett said. “So our biggest year we've ever pumped in the history of Wannacomet was 2025 - last year - when we did 748 million gallons of water during a drought. It's the most water we've ever pumped. When we finish this calendar year, we're going to be at 610 (million gallons), or 615, or 620 million. So we're going to be 120 or 130 million off of last year. So that number is a ways away from 880 (million gallons).”

Screen Shot 2026 11 12 at 12 27 58 PM

The pump station for the new well at North Pasture is currently out to bid, and is expected to cost the Wannacomet Water Company as much as $3 million, Willett told the Water Commission last Thursday. The funding will likely come from retained earnings.

And while Willett and the Commission celebrated the state approval of the new well and the increase in the island’s water withdrawal permit, it wasn’t all good news from the Department of Environmental Protection.

Duane LeVangie, chief of the DEP’s Water Management Program, rejected Willett’s proposal to use a different monitoring well to determine Nantucket’s drought designation.

The state's Drought Management Task Force currently utilizes the United States Geological Survey (USGS) monitoring well 228 off Russell's Way to determine the island's drought status. That well has equipment that radios information about the groundwater table and elevation to the task force.

Willett has previously expressed concern about the well on Russell's Way, stating that it does not always accurately reflect the full picture of groundwater levels on Nantucket because of the soil type in which it was drilled, and lobbied the DEP to utilize an alternative.

“As part of the 2026 permit review, MassDEP reviewed information provided by Nantucket on using Monitoring Well NBW 107 as an alternative to Monitoring Well NBW 228 for triggering nonessential outdoor water use restrictions,” LeVangie wrote. “Well NBW 107 is a shallower well than Well NBW 228 and responds more quickly to precipitation events and dry periods. Nantucket proposed triggering restrictions when groundwater levels in NBW 107 fell to the 10th percentile rather than the 25th percentile trigger at Well NBW 228.

“MassDEP found that the proposal did not meet the goal of regional consistency in nonessential water use restriction triggers for the southeastern part of Massachusetts,” he concluded.

Willett said he had relented on pursuing the change so the permit could be approved, and he will continue to work with the state DEP in 2027 on finding an alternative to well 228.

Current News