Nantucket's 10 Highest Real Estate Sales Of 2025

David Creed •

There were 417 properties sold on Nantucket for over $1.8 billion in 2025 to cap off a relatively busy year for real estate on the island. The Current has compiled a list of the 10 highest sales of the year below.

10) 15 Pleasant Street For $15,450,000

IMG 2933 Large
15 Pleasant Street

9) 14 Bassett Road For $16,434,000

14 Bassett Road
14 Bassett Road

8) 113 Eel Point Road For $16,500,000

113 Eel Point Road
113 Eel Point Road

7) 258 Polpis Road For $16,850,000

258 Polpis Road
258 Polpis Road

6) 1 Ocean Avenue For $18,000,000

1 Ocean Avenue
1 Ocean Avenue

5) 30 Eel Point Road For $19,000,000

30 Eel Point Road
30 Eel Point Road

4) 14 Lincoln Avenue For $21,000,000

14 Lincoln Avenue
14 Lincoln Avenue

3) 86 Pocomo Road For $26,500,000

86 Pocomo630a2a3432bcb
86 Pocomo Road

2) 8 Sachem Road For $31,000,000

8 Sachem Road
8 Sachem Road

1) 3 Sherburne Way For $37,750,000

Photo Oct 09 2025 12 19 04 PM
3 Sherburne Way. Photo by Chris Tran

Current Real Estate