Current Real Estate Roundup - November 5, 2026
David Creed •
This week’s Current Real Estate Roundup includes property transfers from October. 29th, 2026 to November 5th, 2026. It is led by the sale of a Manatook Way property for over $8.5 million, a pair of Sheep Pond Road properties for a combined $7.5 million, an East Lincoln Avenue property for over $7 million, and a Milestone Road property for nearly $5 million.
3 Manatook Way sold for $8,625,000 from Dean Lampe to Three Windrush LLC. The property is .51 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $172,500 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,808,500.
Property Description: "Tucked just moments from the village, this exceptional 'Sconset residence pairs privacy with refined, resort-caliber living. A private pool, expansive outdoor entertaining space, and a thoughtfully composed indoor-outdoor flow set the tone throughout, while high-end custom finishes carry the same level of craft into every room. With four spacious bedrooms plus additional office/sleeping space, a home gym, and a wine cellar, this is a rare offering for anyone seeking a true Nantucket lifestyle property - polished, private, and ready to enjoy from day one."
42 & 44 Sheep Pond Road sold for a combined $7,500,000 from Lucier Nominee Trust to Fiction ACK LLC. The properties combined are 3.68 acres, dwellings, and a Land Bank fee of $150,000 was paid. The assessed value of the properties combined is $7,348,308.
10 East Lincoln Avenue sold for $7,350,000 from Coastal Nominee Realty Trust to Jeff Twombly and Mary C. Twombly. The property is .11 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $147,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $5,071,800.
Property Description: "Nestled in the heart of Brant Point, one of Nantucket’s most coveted seaside neighborhoods, this beautifully appointed four-bedroom home offers an effortless blend of classic island charm and modern comfort. A gracious wrap-around porch welcomes you into a light-filled interior designed for both relaxation and entertaining. Thoughtful details, indoor and outdoor living spaces, and close proximity to both town and the beach make this an ideal Nantucket retreat. Outside, enjoy a private patio with dining and lounge areas, a gas grill, and an outdoor shower. A rooftop widow’s walk crowns the home, offering picturesque harbor views and unforgettable sunsets."
318 Milestone Road sold for $4,875,000 from Michael Hartrick and Sandra Ingrish to James Lovett and Robin Halpern. The property is .46 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $97,500 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $4,981,300.
Property Description: "Sconset Retreat! Sited on a serene half-acre lot abutting the Sconset Land Trust, this bright and spacious, custom-designed contemporary home offers privacy, tranquility, and captivating sunset views—protected in perpetuity. Thoughtfully designed by S.M. Roethke and expertly built by Main Street Construction, the home seamlessly blends architectural elegance with modern functionality. Ideally located just half a mile from the heart of Sconset Village, the property offers easy access to the beach, fine dining, ice cream, and all the classic charm of this beloved Nantucket enclave. The surrounding conservation land enhances the sense of rural calm, while keeping you close to everything. Inside, the beautifully appointed open-concept layout is perfect for contemporary living and entertaining.
"A sun-filled great room includes a gourmet kitchen, dining area, and living room — anchored by a large marble island, wood-burning fireplace, custom built-ins, and a handsome bar. French doors extend the living space outdoors to a covered back deck, bluestone patio, and a charming hip-roof gazebo — ideal for alfresco dining and enjoying Nantucket’s iconic sunsets. Soaring ceilings, oversized windows, and an abundance of natural light create an airy and inviting ambiance throughout the main level. The home’s generous proportions and intelligent flow enhance both comfort and livability. The lower level, while unfinished, features high ceilings, multiple egress windows, rough plumbing, and a full exterior staircase — making future expansion both simple and versatile. This property is located in the town sewer district. Approximately 600 square feet of ground cover remains available."
9 Pond View Drive sold for $4,500,000 from Jay W. Wertheimer Revocable Trust to Nine Pond View Drive Trust. The property is 1.80 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $90,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,871,000.
135 Surfside Road sold for $4,400,000 from William R. Schutt, Trustee of William R. Schutt Revocable Trust & Laurie Ruth Schutt, Trustee of the Laurie Ruth Schutt Revocable Trust to Lindsey M. Gray, Trustee of the Lindsey M. Gray 2025 Trust u/d/t dated October 9th, 2025. The property is .57 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $88,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,403,800.
Property Description: "Hear the ocean from this immaculate four bedroom home, which offers three full bathrooms, multiple living areas, privacy, and mature landscaping. Highlights include an expansive deck overlooking the 17x38 foot heated saltwater pool, spa, and firepit, all surrounded by a bluestone patio. Fully renovated with careful attention to detail, the home provides versatile living spaces throughout.
12 Cottage Avenue sold for $4,200,000 from Barbara K. Gardner, Trustee, Barbara K. Gardner 2020 Trust and Philip C. Gardner, Trustee, Philip C. Gardner 2020 Trust to Inglenook Capital LLC. The property is .11 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $84,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,241,500.
Property Description: "Nestled in the heart of the cherished village of Sconset, 12 Cottage Avenue is an iconic home rich in history, charm, and character. Affectionately known as "Grand Central," this meticulously maintained residence is just moments from the village center and beach stairs, seamlessly blending timeless architectural character with renovated interiors, air conditioning, and the added convenience of a garage. Framed by mature gardens, a welcoming covered front porch and private side deck invite quiet mornings, summer gatherings, and the relaxed pace of life that has made Sconset one of Nantucket's most beloved destinations."
12 King Street sold for $3,300,000 from Cuddy Family LLC to Kelly M. Baker and William K. Baker. The property is .22 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $66,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,612,700.
4 Fawn Lane sold for $3,200,000 from Tic T’Ack Toe LLC to Raymond Rocco Monto. The property is .20 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $64,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $537,300.
Property Description: "The Preserve at Fawn Lane is the ideal place to live. Offering five bedrooms, five full baths, and one powder room with quality craftsmanship throughout. Classic Nantucket-style exterior with white cedar shingle siding, architectural asphalt roof, copper flashing, and Andersen windows and doors. Interior features include imperial plaster walls and ceilings, custom millwork, and 8” engineered prefinished white oak flooring in main living areas. Solid-core interior doors with Baldwin polished chrome hardware. Kitchen and baths offer custom cabinetry, premium countertops, Kohler fixtures, designer tile, and frameless glass shower enclosures. High-efficiency mechanicals include multi-zone HVAC with humidification and dehumidification, Wi-Fi thermostats, energy-efficiency testing, and 200 AMP electrical service. Finished lower level includes additional living space, bedroom, gym, storage, and built-ins. Professionally landscaped grounds."
3 Cottage Court sold for $3,178,000 from Melissa Layman to Oakley Brody LLC. The property is .08 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $63,560 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,206,100.
7 Oak Hollow Lane sold for $3,025,000 from Susan J. Tate and Mark J. Hogan to Jeffrey P. Thompson and Anna E. Sibley. The property is .46 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $60,500 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,488,300.
Property Description: "Tucked away on a quiet lane serving just a handful of private residences, this three-bedroom home in the desirable Hummock Pond/Cisco area offers exceptional privacy amid a beautiful, sun-drenched lawn and gardens. Newly connected to town water and town sewer, and with up to approximately 500 square feet of additional allowable ground cover, the property presents a rare opportunity for meaningful expansion and customization. Enjoy the perfect blend of serene seclusion and convenient access to all your favorite Nantucket activities! Experience the finest South Shore beaches, from Miacomet to Cisco, along with easy access to Audubon and Land Bank Trails, and the scenic Cisco bike path. This delightful home is also just moments away from Miacomet Golf Course, Bartlett’s Farm, 167 Raw, Cisco Brewery, the Sustainable Nantucket Farm Stand, and Harvest Garden Nantucket."
8 M Street sold for $2,800,000 from Johnson Revocable Living Trust u/d/t dated November 9th, 2005 to Next Tide LLC. The property is .54 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $56,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,358,000.
Property Description: "Classic Madaket property on an over-sized lot with first floor water views and Land Bank land across the street. Property spans over half an acre and has four structures that include a three bedroom main house, two car garage, barn and a shed. Very private, scenic with close proximity to the beach and harbor."
106 Old South Road sold for $2,400,000 from Sugar & Ollie Realty LLC to Great Harbor Yacht Club Inc. The property is .12 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $48,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $2,054,700.
9 Mary Ann Drive sold for $1,900,000 from White House Trust to Vasil Marinov and Zhaneta Marinov. The property is .16 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $10,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $1,380,700.
1 Arlington Street sold for $1,500,000 from Arlington PPY LLC to Hinshaw Holdings LLC. The property is .20 acres, a dwelling, and a Land Bank fee of $30,000 was paid. The assessed value of the property is $984,900.
